This book was better than I expected. I’m not really a mystery person, but I could not put this book down. Towards the end, I was constantly getting thrown for a loop. This is, in my opinion, a model mystery (of course, as I said before, I am not a mystery person, so please don’t flame me if you read Agatha Christie).
The characters were all very good, and well-developed. I appreciated the change and dynamics of most of them. However, I wouldn’t mind at all if the sole girl the protagonist’s age had not become his girlfriend: this is a pattern which irks me.
I found the setting, though somewhat far-fetched (OK, very far-fetched) entertaining and exciting, which counts in a children’s/young adult book.
This is a book that I would read again and would most definitely recommend to my friends. Sadly, I would not nominate it for the Newbery Medal, or an honor, because in my opinion it isn’t really distinguished and does not contribute to juvenile literature.
See what we are reading for our 2015 Mock Newbery awards by clicking on the categories under 2014-2015 Club in the category list to the left. We love comments from authors and readers in other Newbery clubs. Please feel free to add some!